The killers got the wrong man – innocent plumber John Versace. Now homicide cop reveals the twisted truth of what’s going on inside murderers’ heads as they remain on the run

They thought they had pleased their masters by ruthlessly gunning down a young man outside his western Sydney home… but the killer, or killers, actually got it very, very wrong. 

Innocent plumber John Versace, 23, was shot dead as he got out of his ute at his family’s home in Dalton Avenue in Condell Park, in Sydney‘s south-west, about 10.30pm on May 19.

The shooter unloaded about 10 rounds of bullets, with Mr Versace suffering four gunshot wounds to his chest and stomach. He died at the scene. 

All evidence shows Mr Versace had done never done anything to spark such a ruthless act of retribution from the underworld. And those responsible – no doubt now aware they have made a big mistake – are still on the run almost a month later. 

Now a retired homicide detective with decades of experience investigating cases such as Mr Versace’s sheds light on the possible motivations of the hitmen responsible and the fallout the killing would have caused in the underworld. 

Former Victoria Police officer Charlie Bezzina believes the ‘hit’ on Mr Versace was likely carried out by people on the ‘lower end of the criminal sphere’.

He said instead of feeling guilt over gunning down an innocent man, they would instead be playing the ‘blame game’ and claim that they were given flawed information. 

‘You’re not dealing with professional people. You’re dealing with low educated people and they accept what they’ve been told,’ he told Daily Mail Australia. 

John Versace, 23, was ambushed by a masked shooter as he got out of his ute in the driveway of his family’s home in Sydney’s south-west on May 19 (the young plumber is pictured)

Former homicide detective Charlie Bezzina (pictured) believes those responsible for Mr Versace’s death would ‘not lose any sleep’ over killing an innocent man

‘These shooters would be highly strung and their angst will be so high that they shoot and ask questions later. 

‘They want to do the deeds for their masters and then, bang, bang. Let’s go. That was him…. and then they find out later it wasn’t him.’ 

He said the shooters were unlikely to face any major repercussions for killing the wrong person, with the shooting only putting the actual target on higher alert – giving them time to flee the country and go into hiding. 

Mr Bezzina said those responsible for Mr Versace’s death were unlikely to have done their due diligence to confirm the identity of their intended target. 

‘An undercover operative or a private investigator would have parameters of the law where they’ve got to prove the identity [of the target] but these guys don’t, they’re just flying by the seat of their pants,’ he said. 

‘Have they got a photograph of them? Have they got a car number? Have they got a car? Have they got a specific address he’s been put to?

‘They’re relying on other people to give them the right information. 

‘They’ll say, “you gave us that information, and that’s what we acted upon. So it’s your fault. It’s not our fault”. 

‘So someone comes out of a particular location nearby that might look a little bit similar to the target… they thought that might be the guy coming out and that’ll do.’

Mr Bezzina said cases of mistaken identity were some ‘of the most difficult’ to solve as police rely on people to come forward with information.

Mr Versace (pictured with one of his sisters) had no known criminal history

Mr Versace is pictured with his parents and two sisters 

The 23-year-old was found with four gunshot wounds to his chest and abdomen. Paramedics treated him at the scene but he could not be revived (pictured)

However, this can prove difficult when organised crime figures are subject to a code of silence and witnesses are too fearful for their own safety to talk. 

‘You’ve got to go in with your best case before you arrest people of this type. You don’t want to go in half-heartedly, charge someone and then lose at trial,’ he said. 

‘That’s the thoroughness of these type of investigations, they would be doing everything within their legal power, to get the evidence, to identify these people. 

‘The frequencies of these incompetent criminals is a cause of concern for the police, and that’s why if they’ve got the evidence, I can assure you, they’d be very keen to lay charges sooner than later.’  

Police told Daily Mail Australia on Tuesday the investigation was ongoing but no further details could be provided at this time.

Harrowing footage from a neighbour’s CCTV camera captured Mr Versace’s final moments on his parents’ doorstep where he lived with his sisters. 

Security footage showed Mr Versace reversing his ute up the driveway and parking it very close to the garage door. As he exited the ute, a small silver hatchback, believed to be a Toyota Corolla, parked across the driveway of the home. 

Mr Versace is seen receiving a kiss from his mother in happier times before his cruel death

Mr Bezzina said police the investigation was difficult as underworld figures operate under a code of silence (pictured, CCTV showing the gunman’s car outside Mr Versace’s house)

Police have urged anyone with information, CCTV or dashcam footage to come forward (pictured, forensic officers examining the crime scene)

The male gunman, dressed in black and wearing a face covering, got out of the backseat and approached the front of the house. 

‘Hey, hey, hey, hey, stop, stop,’ a man is heard yelling before the gunman raised his right hand and opened fire with a Glock-style weapon. 

Police later received reports of a car, which police believe was stolen in December, about 12km away in Fairfield Heights.

A handgun similar to a Glock-style pistol was found inside the vehicle after firefighters extinguished the flames. 

‘We believe that this has the hallmarks of a targeted execution. (It is) very brutal, very distressing,’ Superintendent Rodney Hart told reporters at the time. 

Mr Versace’s sister Deanne recently paid a heartbreaking tribute to her ‘beautiful baby brother’ – sharing powerful images and video of highlights of his life on social media.